CrossFit East Bay Rest Day: 05-06-08 Strong Women are (Still) Beautiful!

| | Comments (1)

Miriam_KB_OHS (Medium).JPG

Miriam Kettlebell OHS @ Berkeley Ironworks




Strong Women Are Beautiful: excellent article on women's body image.

While I cannot fully advocate the ultra-high calorie and rather carb-heavy diet described in the above article, it is a hell of a lot better than the salad and low-fat cookie diet which has been foisted upon our nation's women ("Snackwells" are the devil) by so-called "Women's Magazines". Real women need fat and protein in their diet and muscle on their bodies.

I often hear women say they don't want to "have big muscles" or "get bigger". Well I'm not in the business of making you weak, and I refuse to buy into the idea that women should be weak! Perhaps you have some metabolically inert material you can remove so that you can gain muscle with no net displacement of body mass? Women need muscle mass to avoid osteoporosis, not to mention the fact that in the absence of quality muscle anyone, male or female, looks, well, weak. Is that really what you want? If so I suggest you avoid CrossFit, which will make you strong, and stick to bouncy-ball arm curl and cable-leg spasms, er I mean "exercises". You will be nice and weak even after years of doing them!

Some of the reasons female clients give for being worried about lifting weights:

* don't want big muscles

* only want to "tone" or "lengthen" their muscles

* don't want to "look like a man"


These concerns are baseless and can lead to women neglecting one of the most effective tools for preventing osteoporosis, and maintaining optimum health. To begin with, unless a woman is off the charts in terms of ability to develop muscle, she will not be able to gain significant muscle mass, even should she want to, without truly Herculean (or Amazonian) effort. Women generally do not have enough Testosterone to support large muscles. There are, of course, exceptions such as Olympic Sprinter Marion Jones, but even an athlete so gifted as she in ability to gain muscle mass felt the need to chemically enhance her testosterone levels. So we see that getting big muscles is not a concern, nor should it stop women from lifting weights.

The idea that muscles can be "toned" or "lengthened" by special or unique exercises is false. Despite the claims of some Yoga and Pilates practitioners, this is not possible. The shape of one's muscles, and, hence, limbs and torso, is the product of three things:

* Genetic shape of the muscles
* amount of muscle mass
* amount of "inert metabolic material" (fat)


You were born with muscles which have the same basic shape they do now, and they will continue to have that shape your whole life. This can easily be seen by looking at a few people's calves. Some have an insertion point high on the leg, and therefore look round and more muscular. Others have a lower insertion point, and look longer and leaner. There is no way to change this. However, you can add some muscle mass which will make your limbs look fuller and more shapely, which brings us to our last point. No matter how shapely or toned your muscles are, if they are covered in a thick layer of fat, they won't have much definition. Women generally should maintain 13-21% bodyfat for a combination of optimum health, athleticism and aesthetics, however a higher bodyfat percentage is still healthy (up to around 28%, although estimates vary). Just as too much fat is unhealthy and aesthetically undesirable too little will detract from health, athletic ability and a pleasing shape. As a caveat to the above, even lower bodyfat can have some benefit for activities which require an exceptional strength to weight ratio (such as climbing). I think the lower limit for women should be 11% bodyfat, and even this will tend to make you look drawn, in my opinion. Maintaining such a low bodyfat level without suffering ill effects, such as amenorrhea, or decreased muscle mass and bone density requires an exceptional diligence in one's diet (think zone-paleo)

Thinking that lifting weights will make you "look like a man" is misguided. Perhaps, if you try really, really hard, you might after some years of effort develop a look like Linda Hamilton in "Terminator 2" (yes, I realize she is smoking), Demi Moore in "GI Jane" or Angela Basset in just about anything. Would that be so bad?

Lifting weights is a wonderful health-giving activity for all people, and that includes all women. It builds bone density, prevents osteoporosis, burns calories up to 24 hours after you have finished doing it and contributes to overall health and prevents decrepitude. You would like to be able to walk when you get older right?

LISTEN TO MISTRESS KRISTA!!

Categories

1 Comments

MT

Yay Max! I am so glad you posted this. I told one of my good friends from home that I've been doing CrossFit (and loving it!) and her exact words were "Ew! Are you getting beefy?" I just laughed, but I'm definitely going to send her the link to this. I would take my muscles over twig arms any day!! :-)

New Club Records

2012
1RM Front Squat Fabien: 405

Facebook

Google Search

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Maximus published on May 5, 2008 5:14 PM.

CrossFit East Bay Rest Day 5-05-08: IRON was the previous entry in this blog.

CrossFit East Bay: Test Pilots Needed is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

Powered by Movable Type 4.32-en

Start Here

HOW TO JOIN CROSSFIT EAST BAY

If you are new to CrossFit or CFEB email, click to learn more, or call: 510-910-2919

Schedule
Rates

Next On-Ramp Classes

Contact/Location

info@crossfiteastbay.com

Trainers/Maximus (Owner)
Trainers/Doron(DRG Contact)
Trainers/Ynez
Trainers/Rafael
Trainers/Andrea (CF Body)


CrossFit East Bay at GWPC
520 20th Street
Oakland CA
94612
Map Page